I always thought the Reuben had originated in Germany and was the national sandwich or something. After a little research, I find that it was named after Arthur Reuben, the delicatessen owner from New York who created it. Or at least that's one story. There were a couple of different ones. Not that it really matters. Well, it might matter to Arthur.
After having a most excellent one in Helen, Georgia, about a week ago, I just had to buy the ingredients to make my own. Let me tell you right now, the ingredients were a little pricey. The corned beef was $7.98 per pound and by the time I got the rest of the ingredients, I estimate it was about 16.00. However, I was able to make eight sandwiches, which comes to about 2.00 a piece, which isn't bad.
Most Reuben recipes call for Russian dressing or Thousand Island dressing, but I had neither because I forgot about that part when I was at the store, so I came up with my own and I am so glad I did. Quite frankly it turned out really, really well. I'm just going to call it the "Special Sauce". I had everything to make it in my pantry. I love it when that happens.
Now the one I had in Helen is definitely the best one I ever had. It was very succulent and juicy. Their meat is marinated in something-I don't know what- but it really makes a moist sandwich. But let me say that this one is really, really delicious and we all thoroughly enjoyed them.
The Reuben Sandwich
The special sauce:
1 cup mayonnaise
1/2 cup ketchup
1/8 teaspoon paprika
1/2 teaspoon horseradish
3 tablespoon grated onion
1 teaspoon Worcestershire sauce
1/2 teaspoon celery seed
Salt and pepper to taste
- Whisk together the first 7 ingredients. Add salt and pepper to taste. This was more than enough to make 7 sandwiches.
For one sandwich:
2 Jewish rye bread slices
The special sauce
2 Swiss cheese slices
About 3 tablespoons of sauerkraut that has been well drained
2-3 deli slices of corned beef
Softened butter for spreading the bread
- Preheat a griddle or large skillet.
- Spread one side each of the bread slices with the special sauce. Place a slice of cheese on top of each slice. Spread a couple of spoonfuls of sauerkraut on top of the cheese on one of the slices. Layer a couple of corn beef slices on the sauerkraut, then place the second slice of bread on top, cheese side in. Butter the outside of the sandwich on both sides and place on the griddle over low heat. Cook until golden brown and melted on the inside.
To make the special sauce, place 1 cup of mayonnaise in a bowl and add 1/2 cup of ketchup...
..an 1/8 teaspoon paprika...
...a heaping 1/2 teaspoon of horseradish...
...1 teaspoon Worcestershire sauce...
... and about 3 tablespoons grated onion or about half a medium-ish onion. Make sure that you scrape all the onion juice off of the cutting board into the bowl. There is lots of flavor there. Oh yeah, one more thing...
...1/2 teaspoon celery seeds. These are the tiniest seeds ever and when you spill them on your counter they go everywhere.
Now give it a whisk. I just love whisking things.
When everything is combined, you will probably need to add some salt to your liking...
...and black pepper. I love mine coarsely ground.
Now the sauce is done. Let's make the sandwich.
Make sure you drain your sauerkraut.
Take your Jewish Rye...
..and lay out as many slices as sandwiches you are making. That sentence didn't flow very easily and it was actually not accurate. Let me rephrase this...you will need TWICE as many slices of bread as sandwiches you will be making. I am making two sandwiches in this batch, so I am laying out four slices of bread.
Spread the Wonderful Special Sauce over one side of each slice. Yes, I am now calling it "wonderful" because I just tried some after it has sat in the fridge overnight and the flavors have fused and it has now reached the "wonderful" state.
Take your cheese...
...and lay one slice on each sauced-up side of bread.
Pile on some kraut, but just on one slice per sandwich.
Now, layer some slices of corned beef on top of the kraut...
...and place the other slice of bread on top. Butter the outside well...
...and place on a griddle over low heat. Don't cook it over high heat or the outside will get too dark before the inside has time to get hot and melted. It really helps to have your ingredients at room temperature.
Cook until golden brown.
This is definitely one of my favorite sandwiches.
I made two extra sandwiches for my husband last night because he needed something for his lunch today and I didn't want to get up this morning and cook them, although I DID get up at 5:00 this morning because I am like a total Proverbs 31 woman and I, you know, "rise while it is still dark", JUST like the Bible tells me to do in Proverbs 31, but I, uh, don't want to cook in the morning, I want to drink coconut cream flavored coffee in total silence and, uh, surf the web, uh, I mean read my Bible and have a quiet time so I can be a better mother and wife.
So anyway, I made him two sandwiches so he could take his lunch to school, so he wouldn't have to spend any money for lunch, because he is an SWBTL, well actually, a TWBTL (Teacher Who...blah, blah, blah) and because of his sacrifice, we have extra money to buy coconut cream flavored coffee cream, which is not a necessity, I know, but I can't help it because my sister got me hooked on the stuff.
I said all that to say this. These things that are pictured right here below what I am typing...
...are deli waxed paper sheets. They are the HANDIEST things to have in your kitchen. I buy mine at Sam's and I get 2 boxes of 500 sheets each for about $12.00, which sounds like a lot, I know, but this supply lasts me a long, long time, like maybe even two years. I use them for EVERYTHING: covering things in the microwave so they won't splatter, lining the bottoms of my cake pans before I make cakes to prevent sticking, and wrapping all kinds of food up, like those Reubens that my sacrificing husband took with him this morning. A sandwich will be better off wrapped in deli paper so that it can breathe. Putting sandwiches in plastic sandwich bags can make them suffocate and die because they can't breathe. Actually, it makes them soggy. Therefore , when I made the Reubens for my husband, I wrapped them in this paper and stuck them in a brown paper bag, a lot like they would do at a deli. He can pop them in the microwave and heat them up, and although they won't be exactly as crispy and crunchy as they are when they come right off the griddle, they will still be very delicious. This is one of my favorite kitchen supplies. I just wanted to share this with you.